Hello readers! This blog is a response to the thinking activity on Samuel Beckett 's shortest Play - Breath : Interpretation Challenge, given by Dr.Dilip sir barad - Department of English, Bhavnagar University. This blog is a part of our thinking activity in which we have to do a Picturization of the Play and also interpret it in our own way. Samuel Beckett 's play - Breath is open for an interpretation.
At Present we are studying Samuel Beckett 's another Famous Play - 'waiting for Godot '. While discussing about Beckett 's famous works we came to know about his play - Breath which is one of the very shortest Play and it contains total thirty two seconds.
The script of the play:
CURTAIN Up
1. Faint light on stage littered with miscellaneous rubbish. Hold about five seconds.
2. Faint brief cry and immediately inspiration and slow increase of light together reaching maximum - together in about ten seconds. Silence and hold for about five seconds.
3. Expiration and slow decrease of light together reaching minimum together (light as in 1) in about ten seconds and immediately cry as before. Silence and hold about five seconds.
CURTAIN Down
In this blog, I will try to do Picturization and Interpretation of the Play.
So Let's Start...
• My Picturization of the Play :-
• My Interpretation of the Play :-
I used so many objects in my video. I used total three major sounds in my entire video.
1. Heavy Breathing Sound
2. Horror Sound
3. Baby crying Sound
I Interpreted in Such a way that When we were in some Particular Field at that time all the things become very important, necessary and Essential for us. We think that Without this or that our work will not be done. But by the time we realised that It all became very out of use. We felt that what is the use of all this things now and Suddenly we found it very Meaningless. For Example, When I was in my B.Ed Program at that time I used to think like that The work we were Preparing and the Objects we were using was very essential. But, As the time Passes we felt that Now what is the use of all that things that we have used during that time? Suddenly we found it totally meaningless exactly like our existence on this earth. Our Journey is only From birth to death. From Mother's womb to tomb. Between them all things we found is without any kind of purpose, meaningless and nothingness. So The way we found the objects useless in a same way we also found our existence meaningless.
So, This is my Picturization and Interpretation of this Play.
I hope that this blog will be interesting for you..
Hello readers! Here I am going to write down one another blog. This blog is inspired by Yesha Ma'am - Department of English, Bhavnagar University. This blog is a part of our thinking activity. In this blog I am going to deal with the question about - ' Write a detailed note on the Characteristics of Comedy of Menace. '
As we are Studying about Theatre of Absurd and Different types of comedies. There are mainly Seven types of Comedies and Comedy of menace is one of them.The types of comedies are given as below or under..
1. Sentimental Comedy
2. Comedy of Humours
3. Comedy of Errors
4. Farce
5. High comedy and Low comedy
6. Comedy of manners
7. Comedy of Menace
So, These are the important and major Seven types of comedies. Let's try to discuss in brief about each type of the comedies.
(1). Sentimental Comedy :- Sentimental Comedy is an 18th century dramatic genre which Sprang up as a reaction to the immoral tone of English Restoration Plays. In sentimental Comedies middle class protagonists triumphantly overcome a series of moral trials. These plays aimed to produce tears rather than laughter.
(2). Comedy of Humours :- Comedy of Humours was introduced by Ben Jonson in English drama. The Comedy of Humours was the natural expression of his genius. The term humour as used by Ben Jonson is based on an Ancient Psychological theory of Four fluids found in the human body. Ben Jonson 's comedies are called comedy of Humours because the Principal characters in all the comedies are victims of one human or the other. For Example , he uses Comedy of Humours in his play - ' Every Man in his humour.'
(3). Comedy of Errors :- Comedy of Errors is also one of the important types.
( 4 ). Farce :- Farce is a comedy that seeks to entertain an audience through situations that are highly exaggerated, extravagant, ridiculous, absurd and improbable. Farce is also characterized by heavy use of Physical humour , the use of deliberate absurdity or nonsense , satire, parody and mockery of real life- situation, People, events and interactions.
(5). High comedy and Low Comedy :-
High comedy or Pure Comedy is a type of comedy characterized by Witty dialogue, satire, biting humor, Wordplay or Criticism of life. The term High Comedy was coined in England in the Year 1877 by George Meredith for his Essay on Comedy.
Low Comedy also known as lowbrow humor in association to Comedy is a dramatic or literary form of Popular entertainment without any Primary purpose other than to create laughter through boasting, drunkenness, Scolding Fighting , buffoonery and Other riotous activity. The term Low comedy was coined by John Dryden in his Preface to his Play - ' An Evening 's love'.
(6). Comedy of Manners :- Comedy of manners , Witty form of dramatic comedy that depicts and Often Satirizes the manners and affections of a contemporary society. A Comedy of manners is concerned with social usage and the question of Whether or not characters meet certain social standards.
The Plot of Such a Comedy usually concerned with an illicit love affair or similarly scandalous matter is subordinate to the Play 's brittle atmosphere , Witty dialogue on human foibles.
(7). Comedy of Menace :- Comedy of Menace is the body of plays written by David campton, Nigel Oennis , N.F.Simpson and Harold Pinter. The term was coined by drama critic Irving wardle who borrowed it from the subtitle of Campton' s play - ' The Lunatic View - A Comedy of Menace.'
Here The title - Comedy of Menace immediately brings contradictions to mind because comedy is generally something that makes people laugh and the word Menace implies something threatening. So, here one can easily understand that ;
• Comedy :- Laughter , Humour
• Menace :- A Threatening fear in mind
• Comedy + Menace = Comedy of Menace
The term - The Comedy of menace is a tragedy with a number of comic elements.It is a comedy which also produces an overwhelming tragic effect. Throughout the Play we are kept amused and yet throughout the Play we find ourselves also on the brink of terror. Some indefinable and vague fear keeps our nerves on an edge. We feel uneasy all the time even when we are laughing or smiling with amusement. This dual quality gives to the Play a unique character.
Now let us come back to our final question that what are the main and chief characteristics of the comedy of Menace.
• Chief characteristics of The Comedy of Menace :-
After Understanding the concept about Comedy of Menace we can also noticed that what are the chief characteristics of it. So here I observed some important points which one has to look upon while we are discussing about the term called - comedy of menace.
• Comedy of Menace is a type of humor that deals with dark subjects such as violence and suffering.
For Example:- In the Play - ' The Birthday Party ' by Harold Pinter. We can noticed the violence through the Characters of Goldberg and Macan.while Stanley weaber suffered because of that.
• It often features characters who are in Perilous or uncomfortable situations and uses irony, Sarcasm and Absurdity to create a sense of unease or discomfort in the audience while still being comedic.
• The humor in this type of comedy is often found in the contrast between the horrific subject matter and the absurdity of the situation.
• The comedy of menace literally establishes the outer reality as a force of threatening to the inner space of an individual.
• The situation and circumstances looks absolutely perfect and normal.
• But One can find a kind of unsettling horror and uncomfortable feeling is set beneath the action in the Play.
• Language plays a significant role when it comes to the comedy of menace.
• It exposes the fear, Frustration and Violence of the characters through language.
• The loss of Identity can be also observed in the comedy of menace.
For Example:- The powerful characters like - Goldberg and Macan attacks the weaker character for instance. Stanley Webber suffers from loss of Identity when he is attacked verbally.
• The movement of facial expression and mental depression is depicted through comedy of Menace.
Covering Comedy and Fear at the same time in a play that is a strange art practice in the comedies of menace. One of the most prominent authors who intermingles the two in his plays is - Harold Pinter. This type of comedies also known as Tragicomedy. Including Pinter's Play - The Birthday Party, there are some other works also by Harold Pinter which can be Categorised as a Comedy of Menace.
1. ' The Room ' (1957)
2. ' The Birthday Party ' ( 1958)
3. ' The Dumb Waiter ' ( 1960)
4. ' The Caretaker ' (1960)
5. ' The Homecoming ' ( 1965)
Among all this Plays by Harold Pinter. Let us discuss his Play - 'The Birthday Party' which can be seen as one of the best example of Comedy of menace.
• The Birthday Party as a Comedy of Menace :-
Before we start discussion about how this play considered as a Comedy of menace , First it is very much important to know about the author and his Play.
Harold Pinter :- Harold Pinter was a British Playwright, Screenwriter, Director and actor. He was born on 10th October in the year 1930. A Nobel prize winner Pinter was one of the most influential modern British dramatists with a writing career that spanned more than 50 years. Harold Pinter also directed or acted in radio, stage, television and film productions of his own and Other's works.
His Plays are noted for their use of understatement, Small talk , reticence , and even silence to convey the substance of a character's thought. In the year 2005 Pinter won Nobel prize for literature.
' The Birthday party ' :-
The Birthday Party ( 1957) is the first full - length Play by Harold Pinter. This play first published on 28th April in the year - 1958. Originally written in English language. It is one of his best - known and most frequently performed plays.
The Play has been classified as a Comedy of menace, Characterised by Pinteresque elements such as ambiguous identity, Confusion of time and Place and dark political Symbolism.
• Elements of Comedy of Menace in the Play ' The Birthday party' :-
One can find Comic as well as terrific elements in Harold Pinter 's play The Birthday party. This play has been described as a comedy of menace because the consistent flow of fear and horror is symbolically presented in Characters mind. ' Pinter actually exposes the State of modern man and the idea of fear that exists in human mind.'
Stanley weaber who is a protagonist of this play. He is such a character who tries to protect himself from the outer society. Printer's play often does not give a brief description of the past of character 's life. As we also don't know that what happened with Stanley weaber in his past. The fear of Stanley is noticeable throughout the Play.
When Meg discovers that two strangers will come to stay at boarding house at that time Stanley behaved violently to Meg's announcement. Stanley actually reflects modern man Isolation and a kind of fear that exists in modern man from being exposed to outer reality. The outer reality becomes a threat to their inner space which they like to avoid and disconnects easily.
When Goldberg and Maccan asking questions to Stanley at that time also they were not giving Stanley a chance for even answering the questions. So that is how we can understand that how they both verbally attacked on Stanley weaber. As a audience and as a viewer we felt some kind of fear and Threatening effect that what will happen in the very next movement. Through their acting Characters what to create comic atmosphere but Inside they are very much in stress and in depression like our Protagonist- Stanley weaber. So that is how Comic + Terrible and fearful effect in one's mind that is one of the main Characteristics in this play.
The Feeling of Fear is very common in Harold Pinter 's plays. and especially In The Birthday Party the existential fear is very Present. Stanley Webber does not want to step out from the house because he had a fear of something which already happened in the past.
Let's sum up...
Conclusion :- To conclude one can understand that Comedy of menace means the audience knows nothing about the characters and their past. But while watching it creates the atmosphere of suspense and menace.
welcome readers! Here I am going to write down one blog on the topic of Indian Poetics. This blog is inspired by Dr. Dilip barad sir - Department of English, Bhavnagar University. This blog is also a part of our thinking activity. As a Student of literature it is very much Intresting to know about the Study of Indian aesthetics and Indian poetics. In this Particular blog I am going to share my basic understanding about this topic.
As we have the Paper of Literary Theory & Criticism and Indian Aesthetics in our syllabus of M.A Semester- 2. we all got a chance to attend Vinod sir Joshi's lecture From 5th to 13th January at English Department. It is an honour and Opportunity for all of us that we can learn about this interesting topic as well as other things which is related to language and literature from a very recognised and respected professor, Poet, Dr.Vinod sir Joshi. We also invited the students from Gujarati Department as well. Overall, we all had such a wonderful sessions by sir and Spent good time together.
For the Floral welcoming of sir We decided One student from our Department and another one from Gujarati Department and that is how two students welcomed sir by giving them Flower and greeting card.
One of my Classmate - Avni Jani had done Anchoring for the very first day of Guest lecture and I gave a very brief Introduction of Vinod Joshi Sir.
So, Here are some Glimpses of the very First day of Guest lecture.
• What is Indian poetics?
Oxford English Dictionary defines Poetics as ' Art of Writing Poetry ' Or ' the Study of Poetry '.
Poetics is a Study of such work of art individually or collectively. Literature differs from other writing in its use of language. Indian Scholars were aware about the Uniqueness of language used in literature.They knew and there was a general agreement that sound and sense are the two important elements blending of which makes Poetry what it is. The different schools or sampradays - рк╕ંркк્рк░ркжાркпો of Indian Poetics emerged out of different speculations about the way in which the blending of sound and sense takes place.
Poetics is both Science as well as Philosophy. Indian poetics Starts with Bharata's Natyashastra, Passes through Bhamaha Dandin, Vamana and attains vastness in the Writings of Anandvardhana, Abhinavgupta, Vishwanatha, and Pandit Jagannatha.
Sanskrit Word for Poetics is Kavyashastra. Another word used for Poetics is Kavyamimansa. Mimansa means Study, discussion and Inquiry. The word Kavyamimansa was first Used by Rajasekhara - a tenth century Poet from Kashmir.
In Indian poetics we found six different schools or theories which are given as below or under.
1. Rasa theory by Bharatamuni
2. Dhvani theory by Anandvardhana
3.Vakrokti theory by Kuntaka
4. Alankara theory by Bhamah
5. Riti by Vaman
6. Auchitya by Ksemendra
Let us try to discuss and Understand them in detail.
1. The Rasa theory :-
In Indian aesthetics, a rasa ( рд░рд╕) literally means ' nectar, essence or taste.' It connotes a concept in Indian arts about the aesthetic Flavour of any visual , literary or musical work that evokes emotion or feeling in the reader or audience but cannot be described. Rasas are created by bhavas, the state of mind. Bharata Muni is regarded the Father of Indian Rasa theory. He gave major statement in his book ' Natyashastra.'
Bharata the great rhetorician has tried to explain that how this aesthetic Pleasure takes place. He has tried to give the theory of rasa in one Sutra as he says that ;
• Bhayanaka rasa :- Terrific and Terrible Sentiments
Represents horror, Terror, or one kind of Fear and anxiety.
Colour :- Black
• Bibhatsa rasa :- Odious Sentiments
Represents Disgust and aversion
Colour:- Blue
• Adbhuta rasa :- Marvellous Sentiments
Represents Wonder, Mystery or Curiosity.
Felling of Amazement
Colour :- Yellow
• Shanta rasa :- Relaxation Sentiments
Represents Peace and the State of Calmness.
Colour :- Perpetual white
In Response to Bharatamuni 's Rasa theory Four Scholars emerged and they gave their different Opinions and Point of views.
1. Bhatt Lollatt :- Bhatt Lollatt argues that there is no rasa. But,rather it is being Produced. This Concept of Bhatt Lollatt considered as 'ркЙркд્рккркд્ркдિрк╡ાркж'.
2. Shree Shankuk :- Shree Shankuk argues that there is no rasa nor it is produced. But one can only Supposed it. These Supposition are of total Four types. This Concept of shree Shankuk Considered or known as ' ркЕркиુркоркдિрк╡ાркж'.
рез. рдпрдеाрд░्рде рдк्рд░рддिрддी |
реи. рд╕ाрджृрд╢्рдп рдк्рд░рддिрддी |
рей. рд╕ंрд╢рдп рдк्рд░рддिрддी |
рек. рдоिрде्рдпा рдк्рд░рддिрддी |
3. Bhatt Nayaka :- Bhatt Nayaka argues that there is no rasa. It can not being Produced and it can not even supposed. But, It is experienced or Simplified. ркЕркнિркиркп ркХрк░ркиાрк░ркоાં рк░рк╕ркиું рк╕ાркШાрк░ркгીркХрк░ркг ркерк╡ું ркЬોркИркП ркд્ркпાрк░ркмાркж ркк્рк░ેркХ્рк╖ркХોркоાં ркеાркп ркЫે.
• рк╕ાркШાрк░ркгીркХрк░ркг :- ркУркдркк્рк░ોркд Or Total, Complete Involvements .
4. Abhinavgupta :- Abhinavgupta argues that Rasa can be generated only when Nat - Nati, Audience and creator Predict Bhavas and then shows total Involvements in it.
The Dhvani school of poetry was Formulated by Anandvardhana who wrote 'Dhvanyaloka'
in the middle of the 9th century. It brought Focus on the Potential Power of the Word in a Kavya. Here, the word together with its literal Sense forms the body of kavya.
1. Abhidha :- Abhidha is the first and basic shabda Shakti. Other two Shaktis rest upon it. Abhidha may be defined as that Power of words which Conveys the Conveys the Conventional meaning or the literal meaning of the expression.
2. Lakshana :- Lakshana is the Second Shabda Shakti. It is Indication Power. It consists in the external characteristics of the expression which are indicative of something deeper.
3. Vyanjana :- vyanjana is the third Shabda Shakti which means suggestive. In Vyanjana we get direct meaning but it is incomplete. So we have to take another meaning that is called Vyanjana.
1. Vastu Dhvani :- This is the very first type of Dhvani. In Vastu Dhvani some rare of Idea is implied. In Vastu Dhvani one can see and understand that Thought is at the centre. This type of Dhvani also known as рк╡િркзેркпાркд્ркоркХ ркз્рк╡ркиિ.
2. Alankara Dhvani :- This is the Second type of Dhvani. In Alankara theory some Alankara or figure of speech is suggested.
3. Rasa Dhvani :- This is the third and last Part of Dhvani. In Rasa Dhvani rasa is evoked.
The Indian poetics hs always deliberated on the meaning of words in literature. Another school we found that emphasized meaning in poetry is Vakrokti. Sanskrit word Vakrokti is a compound of two words.
• Vakra :- Crooked, bent
• Ukti :- Saying or expression
• Vakra + Ukti :- Vakrokti
So Vakrokti means Oblique expression. Let Us understand this with one very beautiful example.
Kuntaka is Credited for the Propagation of this theory. He lived between 950 - 1050 AD. His Vakroktijivitam ( рд╡рдХ्рд░ोрдХ्рддिрдЬीрд╡िрддрдо рдЧ्рд░ंрде ) is a landmark work in Indian poetics, In which he talked about Vakrokti theory.