Welcome readers! This blog is written in response to the task assigned by Dr.Dilip Barad sir from Department of English, MKBU. This blog deals with the Concept of Cyberfeminism.Click here to readmore about this task. So, In this blog I am reflecting my understanding about the topic Cyberfeminism. Before discussing more about it First, Let us have a look at the meaning of Cyberfeminism.
Cyber - Feminism
◇ What is Cyber - feminism :-
Cyberfeminism is a Feminist approach which foregrounds the relationship between cyberspace, the Internet and technology. It can be used to refer a Philosophy, methodology or Commumity. The term was coined in the early 1990s to describe the work of feminists interested in theorizing, critiquing, exploring and re - making the Internet , Cyberspace and new media technologies in general. Prior to the advent of Cyberfeminism, Feminst study of technology tended to examine technological developments as Socially and culturally constructed. The ranks of Cyberfeminists are growing, however and along with this increase is a growing divergence of ideas about what constitutes Cyberfeminists thought and action.
Technology equally work for everyone. Even though women throughout history have been active in developing new technologies, cyberfeminists have argued that technology has still been looked upon as a masculine creation. So, here the question arises is that ;
" Is technology Bias free ? "
Cyberfeminism is a woman - Centered Perspective that advocates women's use of new information and Communications technologies for empowerment. Some see these technologies as inherently liberatory and argue that their development will lead to an end to male superiority, because women are uniquely suited to life in the digital age. The term Cyberfeminism explicitly fuses gender and information technology, arose in the late 1980s and early 1990s. Cyberfeminism views technology as a tool for the deconstruction of gender stereotypes.
This approach takes advantage of the new era of online media that offers a new space and targets for the movement. Cyberspace and the internet is a virtual world that allows for an immense numbers of opportunities to be created , and visions to be shared globally. Cyberfeminism is not against ideologies, but rather against the structure that creates them. The internet allows for grounds to find a new alternative way to escape these Power Structures that can be limiting to Identity.
" Cyberfeminism is a different way to rebel against Patriarchy. "
◇ What does Cyberfeminists do?
Cyberfeminists were interested in theorizing and critiquing the internet and new media technologies through a Feminist lens.
The history of Cyberfeminism can be linked back to the work of Donna Haraway, a professor in the History of Consciousness program at the University of California at Santa Cruz. Her essay, “A Manifesto for Cyborgs " was groundbreaking for feminists. She argued in her work that women needed to become technologically proficient to challenge systems that didn’t represent equality. Other feminists who are active on the internet believe that it can be a vital space for women to use technology to gain a better position within society. To advance these ideas, individuals who associate with this branch of feminism created websites, discussion groups, and other online resources for women to learn more about technology. These individuals and groups believe that women’s knowledge of new media can create more opportunities for them in technological lines of work.
Bruce Grenville in the Uncanny : Experiments in cyborg culture mentions : " The dominant Cyberfeminists Perspective takes a utopian view of cyberspace and the internet as a means of freedom from social constructs such as gender, sex difference and race. For instance, a description of the concept described it as a struggle to be aware of the impact of new technologies on the lives of women as well as the so called insidious gendering of technoculture in everyday life."
We all have to see that Virtual world is nothing but mirror image of real World. The AI Coders are also human beings. If these Coders are unconsciously biased or are not made about their unconscious gender biases, the artifical intelligence/ machines / robots / algorithms made by them is bound to have similar biases.
Artificial intelligence ( AI) inherits biases from the data it's trained on. When it comes to Cyberfeminism, which focuses on the intersection of gender and technology , this issue is Particularly important. AI systems can Perpetuate unconscious biases against women and gender minorities. For example, if AI Algorithms are trained on historical data that reflects gender inequalities, they might make biased decisions in different areas. So, In that way Algorithms Played an important role in making decisions.
◇ Ted Talks :-
Here are two talks available on Ted Platform. One is of Kirti Sharma about How to keep human bias out of AI? And another is of Robin Hauser about Can we Protect AI from our biases? They both made some of the interesting Observations during their talk.
Talk 1 :- Kirti Sharma: How to keep human bias out of AI?
In these Ted talk by Kirti Sharma she explained that we are told that the biggest worry around the future of AI is not that it will take our jobs but that it will reinforce human biases already present in the sector. She has explained about biases in AI and also her Personal experiences with AI. Further In her talk she said that she has several degrees in computer science and has been building robots from the age of 15, says that based on her apperance and gender it is regularly assumed by everyone that she does not know much about Artificial intelligence. Algorithms are being used all the time to make decisions about who we are and what we want.
She says that these biases are reinforced by the genders we assign to AI - Powered devies. She gives the examples of siri and Alexa , AI technologies with female voices which we are used to giving orders to. While on the other hand , more Powerful Programms such as whatson designated " male."
Future she talked about how all these affect a kid growing up in today's world around AI. She stated that the good news about AI is that it is entirely within our control. We get to teach the right values, and right ethics to AI. For that she suggested 3 things that we all can do.
1. We can be aware of our own biases and the bias in machine around us.
2. We can make sure that diverse teams are building this technology.
3. We have to give it diverse experiences to learn from.
In her talk she gives examples of when AI takes these biases and reinforces them : men are more likely to be Programmers and historically outnumber women in this field ; based on this data , an algorithm designed for recruitment purposes can assume that male applicants are preferable and filter out female candidates, she explains.
" This is not about the talent ; this is about an elitism in AI that a Programmer needs to look like a Certain Person."
To conclude, in her talk, Kirti Sharma highlighted how Artificial Intelligence is infused with gender biases. Both technology and AI are human creations, and unconsciously, they have inherited gender biases and stereotypes.
Talk 2 :- Robin Hauser : Can we Protect AI from our biases?
As humans we are inherently biased. Sometimes it is explicit and other times it is unconscious, but as we move forward with technology how do we keep our biases out of the Algorithms we create? Documentary filmmaker Robin Hauser argues that we need to have a conversation about how AI should be governed and ask who is responsible for overseeing the ethical standards of these supercomputers. She explains in her talk that how the foundations of Artificial intelligence is biased by giving real life examples.
Artificial intelligence technologies are designed by People. That means the foundation on which they Operate is defined by the goals, ambitions and indeed both conscious and unconscious biases of their developers. Understanding and developing ways to tackle these biases is essential in order to provide fair and effective Solutions. She discusses the importance of recognizing and tackling biases and avoiding skewed data that could Prejudice automated decisions and undermine deep learning networks.
In this talk, Robin Hauser tells about her experience working with AI and the biases that can develop by humans teaching the machines and how to avoid these biases when creating algorithms.
◇ Key Insights from these talk :-
- Unconscious bias is a fascinating and disturbing aspect of the human condition that can interfere with our interactions and lead to snap judgments or assumptions.
- Humans are programming bias into artificial intelligence through lack of foresight, malicious intent, skewed data, and letting their own bias seep into the data sets and algorithms they write.
- AI systems rely on data fed to them to train algorithms, highlighting the importance of ensuring diverse and unbiased datasets to avoid perpetuating biases in AI.
- The use of word embedding in machines can lead to the perpetuation of stereotypical biases, highlighting the need to address and mitigate these biases in AI systems.
- Do we want artificial intelligence to reflect the biases of society today or strive for an ideal and equitable society of tomorrow?
□ Conclusion :- To Conclude, safeguarding AI from human biases requires a multi - faceted approach. It involves many techniques. Perhaps, By doing that we all can work towards AI systems that are fair, equitable and less to Perpetuating harmful biases.
I hope that this blog will be helpful to you in understanding the Concept of Cyberfeminism.
Welcome readers! This blog is written in response to the thinking activity assigned by Megha Ma'am from the Department of English at MKBU. In this blog, I will delve into T.P. Kailasam's play, 'The Curse or Karna,' and explore some questions related to the play. My focus will be on the character of Karna and its connection with the Subaltern theory. But before that , let us start by discussing the playwright and the play itself.
' Thinking Activity'
"The Curse or Karna" - Play by T.P. Kailasam
' The Curse or Karna' Play by T.P. Kailasam is a thought-provoking Indian Play that delves into the Complexities of Fate and morality. It explores the Character of Karna from Mahabharta, Shedding light on his inner Struggles and the Injusticies he faced during his life. Kailasam's work is famous for his rich dialogues and Intricate character development, making it a Compelling Piece of literature.
□ T. P. Kailasam :-
Tyagraj Paramasiva Iyer Kailsam ( Kannada - 1884 to 1946) , was an Indian Playwright and Prominent Writer in the Kannada literature. Literary Criticism in Kannada literature is said to have Started for the first time by Kailasam in his works. His Contribution to Kannada theatrical Comedy earned him the title "Prahasana Prapitamaha " (ಪ್ರಹಸನ ಪ್ರಪಿತಾಮಹ; the great grandfther of humorous Plays). He was later often revered " the one and only Kailasam for Kannada.
Kailasam's life was dedicated to local theatre and his Contributions revolutionsed it. His Humour left an impression on Kannadigas. He opposed the Company theatre's obsession with mythology and stories of royalty and shied away from loading his Plays with music. Instead he introduced Special realistic Sets. Kailsam was initially Criticised for modern use of the Kannada language in his Plays at a time when the language was used under Strict lingustic syntax and Semantics. But , soon after his works became very Popular and are Considered among the best in Kannada theatre, known for wit and Satirical Commentary on Society.
T.P.Kailasam is still remembered as a Prominent figure in the Karnataka Theatre Circuit. He wrote humorous Plays.
◇ Kannada Plays :-
● ' ToLLu Gatti '
● ' Poli Kitti , The Story of a born Scout
● ' Bahishkara '
● ' HomeRoolu'
● ' Gandaskatri '
● 'NamkLabbu '
● ' Seekarne Saavitri '
● ' Sattavana Santhaapa ' etc..
◇ English Plays :-
● ' Fulfilment '
● ' Purpose '
● ' The Brahmin's Curse'
Kailasam turned his hand to mythological themes also but treated themes in English. He was a moralist , but he had the Subtletly needed to carry off his moralising. His appreciation of what was really noble in traditional ways of living , added a grace to his Plays. He created the new vogue for the Satirical social Play which Proved that Powerful Prose with Penetrating humour could do away with tinsel attractions of music , Setting and Costume.
T.P.Kailasam died in the City of Bengluru in the state of karnataka in the year 1946.
□ About the Play ' The Curse or Karna '
The Curse or karna is a Play written by T.P.Kailasam , a Prominent Playwright in Kannada literature. The Play is based on Characters and events from the Indian Epic, The Mahabharata , with a major focus on Karna, one of the Central characters. Karna is known for his tragic fate. In this Play Kailasam explores Karna's life , his inner Struggles and the moral dilemmas he faces. The play delves into the themes of Fate, loyalty and the Consequences of one's Choices. It Provides a unique Perspective on Karna's character and adds depth to his Potrayal in Mahabharata.
The Play is divided into Five acts. It was Published on 10th September 1946 and later republished on 29th July 1969. The Setting of the Play is Raama's Ashram. The entire Play is talking about the Character of Karna and how he marginalized because of his Subaltern Identity. Along with that, the Play also talked about the Sufferings of karna throughout his life and at the end he faced Painful death by his own brother.
The Play is well regarded for its dramatic Storytelling and Character development. It remains an important work in Indian literature and theatre, Shedding light on the Complex and tragic figure of karna from the Mahabharata.
Question 1 :- Interpret the 'end' of all acts and Scenes in brief.
Answer :-
Act 1 - Gurujee Raama
" POOR KARNA! POOR, POOR KARNA ! "
Act 2 - Gaandhaara
" POOR ANGA ! POOR POOR HONEST ANGA!"
Act 3 - The King Suyodhan
" The King POOR ANGA ! OUR POOR GREAT ANGA!"
Act 4 - Bheema
( Anga Crumples into Bheema's arms who carries him out muttering amid tears : " POOR ANGA! POOR GREAT ANGA ! " The THRONE ROOM , empty now , is exposed for a minute before - )
Act 5 - Aswattha and Maadra
" OUR ANGA! " OUR GREAT ANGA !
[ " OUR POOR POOR ANGA " ! ]
From these acts and Scenes from the play " The Curse or Karna" by T.P.Kailasam depicts various characters expressing Sympathy and Sorrow for Anga , who is Commoly referred to as " POOR ANGA " or " OUR POOR POOR ANGA." These acts highlight the theme of Anga being seen as a Sympathetic and honorable character who receives Compassion and lamentation from various Individuals in the Play. " The Curse or Karna" by T.P. Kailasam revolves around a recurring theme of empathy and sorrow for Anga, a character who is repeatedly referred to as "POOR ANGA" or "OUR POOR POOR ANGA" in various acts and scenes.
In Act 1, Gurujee Raama sets the tone by expressing pity for Karna, foreshadowing Anga's misfortunes. This initial sympathy hints at the unfolding tragic events.
In Act 2, in the land of Gaandhaara, Anga is portrayed as "POOR POOR HONEST ANGA," emphasizing his virtuous character and the hardships he faces. This highlights his integrity, making the audience sympathize with him.
Act 3 brings King Suyodhan into the narrative, echoing the sentiment by referring to Anga as "OUR POOR GREAT ANGA." The repetition of "poor" underscores the depth of compassion felt for Anga throughout the play.
Act 4 showcases Bheema cradling Anga, lamenting "POOR GREAT ANGA." This poignant scene portrays the culmination of Anga's tragic journey, evoking sympathy from the audience.
Lastly, in Act 5, Aswattha and Maadra join in expressing their grief for "OUR GREAT ANGA," cementing Anga's status as a beloved character. These acts and scenes collectively create a powerful emotional arc, painting Anga as a figure of immense sympathy and honor in the play.
Karna is doomed by Fate. Despite his tragic end, karna remains a Sympathetic character , as he is a Victim of Circumstances and Struggles with his own internal Conflicts.
Question 2 : Karna - the Voice of Subaltern.
Answer :- Karna, often regarded as the "Voice of Subaltern," is a pivotal character in Indian mythology, particularly in the epic Mahabharata. Born to Kunti and the Sun God, Surya, Karna's life is marked by adversity and social exclusion. His lower caste origins and struggles for acceptance symbolize the marginalized voices of society. Despite facing discrimination and hardship, Karna's unwavering loyalty, valor, and tragic destiny resonate with those who identify with the subaltern, making him a powerful symbol of resilience and the enduring struggle for justice. First we have to understand about sublatern theory.
◇ What is Subaltern Theory?
Subaltern theory, developed within the field of post Colonial Studies. It focuses on the voices of and experiences of marginalized and Oppressed groups in Society , often overlooked by dominant narratives. This theory aims to understand the Perspectives of those who have been historically silenced and Subjugated due to factors like caste , class, gender race or nationality.
Sublatern Studies delves into the Complex dynamics of Power and resistance, Shedding a light on the hidden histories and Struggles of Communities. It Challenged established hierarchies and Prompting a more inclusive understanding of Social and political issues.
◇ Karna as Subaltern :-
He refers to the Populations that are Socially, Politically and geographically outside of the legitimate Power structure of the Colony and of the Colonial homeland. Tragic Character with tragic fate. Marginalized by gurus, warriors, Princes, Panchalee, Kings. The term Subaltern was coined by Ranjit Guha and later it was adopted by Marxist Antonio Gramsci and further it was discussed by Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak in her essay ' Can the Subaltern Speak? ' People Consider Subaltern as the unpresented group of People in the Society. People of inferior race, not fit for making any real Contributions to the Society and therefore they cannot Speak. But, In reality Subaltern can speak but others do not have the Patience to listen to them and same can be seen with Karna, he is capable but ultimately he is suta Putra.
Karna, a complex character from the Indian epic, the Mahabharata, is often seen as marginalized due to his social and familial background. He was born to Kunti, a queen, but was abandoned at birth and raised by a charioteer. This low-caste upbringing made him an outsider in the Kuru dynasty, where caste and lineage played a crucial role. Despite his immense talent and valor, Karna faced discrimination and was denied the rights and recognition typically afforded to a prince.
Karna's story resonates with many as a voice of the subaltern, representing those who are marginalized or oppressed by societal norms. His struggle for recognition, his loyalty to Duryodhana despite knowing the moral consequences, and his eventual tragic downfall highlight the plight of those who are pushed to the fringes of society. Karna's character challenges the established social hierarchy, shedding light on the unjust treatment of individuals based on their birth rather than their abilities. In this way, Karna is considered a voice of the subaltern, symbolizing the struggles of those who fight against a system that marginalizes them.
Karna, a prominent character in the Indian epic Mahabharata, can be considered a voice of the subaltern in various ways:
1. Social Marginalization : Karna was born to a low-caste mother and was abandoned as a child. He faced social discrimination and marginalization due to his lower caste, which makes him a representative of the subaltern, who often face oppression based on their social status.
2. Struggle for Identity: Karna's lifelong struggle to establish his identity and gain recognition mirrors the challenges faced by many subaltern individuals who seek to assert their identity and rights in a society dominated by the privileged.
3. Solidarity with the Dispossessed : Throughout the Mahabharata, Karna showed empathy and support for the downtrodden, aligning himself with those who were marginalized or oppressed, reflecting a subaltern perspective of advocating for the rights of the dispossessed.
4. Quest for Justice: Karna's sense of justice and fairness, despite his own disadvantaged position, underscores the subaltern's desire for a just society where everyone is treated equitably.
5. Complex Character: Karna's character is multifaceted, reflecting the complexity of subaltern voices. He is both a tragic hero and a flawed character, highlighting the diverse experiences and struggles within the subaltern community.
Overall, Karna's journey in the Mahabharata can be seen as a representation of the subaltern narrative, highlighting the challenges, aspirations, and resilience of those who are marginalized in society.
Welcome readers ! This blog is written in response to the thinking activity given by Dr.Dilip Barad sir - Department of English, MKBU. The topic of my blog is about Power dynamics and Media in the Cultural Studies. Apart from that, I will also delve into the Profound Insights gleaned from Noam Chomsky's video on what it means to be truly educated. This blog is inspired by Dr. Dilip Barad sir. First, Let's begin by understanding the meaning and essence of cultural studies.
Click hereto know more about Cultural Studies and about this task.
Cultural Studies
- What is Cultural Studies ?
Cultural Studies is an interdisciplinary field, drawing on theories and practices from a range of humanities and social sciences disciplines, that seeks to investigate the ways in which cultures produce and are produced. At the centre of Cultural Studies sits a host of questions, such as what constitutes a text, how some texts, visual images, and cultural artifacts come to be valued over others, and how questions of value relate to the distribution of power and authority. Cultural Studies takes as its focus the whole Complex of Changing ideas, beliefs, Feelings , Values and Symbols that define a Community's Organization and sense of itself. When we Study Culture, we are Studying the world we live in and how we function in it.
Cultural Studies emerged in Britain in the late 1950s and Subsequently Spread internationally, notably to the United States and Australia. It Originally Identified with the centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies at the University of Birmingham ( founded in 1964 ) and with such Scholars as ;
● Richard Hoggart
● Stuart Hall
● Raymond Williams
Cultural Studies later became a well - established field in many academic Institutions, and it has since had broad influence in Other Fields like - Sociology , anthropology, literary Criticism and Philosophy. Among its Central Concerns are the Place of race or ethnicity , class and gender in the Production of Cultural Knowledge.
1. Understanding of Power in Cultural Studies :-
In Cultural Studies , the Concept of Power Occupies a central and multifaceted role. Power is not merely a force of domination but a Complex interplay of idealogies , institutions and Social structure that shape and define Cultural Phenomena. It Operates through discourses that frame how we Perceives and interact with the world , Constructing hierarchies of Identity , class , gender and race. Cultural Studies Scholars investigate how power is exercised through representation , media and language revealing the ways in which dominant groups maintain Control and marginalize Others.
Power is something we are often uncomfortable taking about. That is true in Civc life , how we live together in Commumity. It Played a vital role in Cultural Studies. Nobody is free from the dynamics of Power. Dynamics keeps on Changing evertime and that is why ;
" Power of one Centre, becomes Periphary in another Centre. "
In Democracy, it should be with People. It is important to know about where Power comes from , How it is exercised and what one can do to become more Powerful in Public life. In basic Definition : -
"Power is the ability to make Others do what you would have them do."
This Plays in all arenas of life from family to the Workplace and to our relationships. There are six main Sources of civic Power.
1. Physical Force
2. Wealth
3. State action ( Government)
4. Social norms
5. Ideas
6. Numbers (Quantity)
Cultural Studies is interested in the Process by which Power relations between and Within groups of human beings Organize Cultural artefacts , Such as Food habits , music , Cinema , Sports events and their meanings. There are three laws of Power worth examining.
1. Power is Never Static.
2. Power is like Water.
3. Power Compounds.
It is a useful to think in terms of literacy. It is important to learn that , How to read Power and Write Power. To read Power means to Pay attention to as many texts of Power as one can, it is not about books only. Seeing Society as a set of texts. Check / Map out that who has what kind of Power, arrayed in what Systems. For that to study Stratergies is important. To write Power requires first that believe in Our own self that as a human being we have to right to Write. To be an author of change in Society and do. As we all know that ;
" Any kind of Writing always helps in expressing our own self."
Speak up in a Voice that is authentic. Organize the ideas first and than Organize other People. But still one question is remaining is that ' Why Of Power'. Cultural Studies Scholars delve into the dynamics of Power to Understand how it is resisted and negotiated within Societies. Cultural Studies seeks to reveal hidden inequalities, Challenge dominant narratives and empower marginalized Voices. But , Remember one thing that ;
' Power + Character = Great Citizen " we have the Power to be one.
The Second goal of Cultural studies that it is Politically engaged. Cultural critics see themselves as oppositional , not only within their own disciplines but to many of the Power Structures of society at large. The Second goal of Cultural studies is about recognizing that Culture is not Seperate from Politics but intricately Connected to it.
Michel Foucault , French Philosopher , French Philosopher and Historian. He gave the idea about Power and Knowledge. He argued that Knowledge and Power are intimately bound up. So much so, he coined the term Power / Knowledge to point out that one is not seperate from the another one. He challeneges the idea of Power and Says that ;
" Power is everywhere".
Michel Foucault is one of the few writers on Power who recognize that Power is not just a negative or repressive thing that forces us to do something against our wishes, but can also be a necessary, Productive and positive force in our Society. A key point about Faucault's approach to Power is that it transcends Political and Sees Power as an everyday, Socialised and embodied Phenomenon.
2. Why Media Studies is so important in our Digital Culture ?
Answer :- Media Studies is important in the Context of Digital Culture because it equips individuals with the analytical tools. Media Studies fosters Critical thinking , enabling individuals to discern between credible Information and misinformation. Ultimately , Media Studies Played a vital role and informed Citizenship in the Digital age. Media is a broad field which talks about History as well as Contemporary times.
" Media Studies is a discipline and field of study that deals with the Content, history and effects of Various media ; in Particular , the Mass Media."
Media Studies and Cultural Studies are Connected with each other. Advertising , Marketing and Critique are all features associated with Media. The role of the media is to provide accurate and truthful information to people. However, in contemporary times, this is often not the case. We tend to unquestioningly accept what is presented to us and share it without verifying its accuracy. The media exerts significant influence over the masses.
When we talk about Manufacturing of Consent the question arises that whose Consent is being manufactured? Noam Chomsky explained in the video that elite media are the sort of agenda - setting media , that means the ' New York Times' , ' The washington Post' , and major television Channels. They determine, they select, they shape , they Control , they restrict in order to serve the interests of the dominant elite groups in Society. From these Point we can understand that Media is holding a Power. It is important to know that who is in the Power and Who Owns a Media? If we watch various news channels and then compare them, we may discover that some channels attempt to conceal the actual news, and it appears that those in power also influence news outlets.
- Five Filters of Media given by Noam Chomsky. They are ;
We watched a video as part of our classroom studies in which we gained insights into the relationship between journalism and power. One female journalist was supporting those in power, while another male journalist consistently questioned and aimed to uncover the truth.
3. Who can be Considered as a ' Truly Educated Person '?
Education is not the mere acquisition of Knowledge and Skills. Instead , it is about thinking creatively and Critically as well.
In Noam Chomsky's video about what makes a truly educated person, he emphasizes the importance of critical thinking and independent inquiry. He argues that being truly educated is not just about memorizing facts and information but rather about developing the ability to question, analyze, and challenge existing knowledge and ideas. Chomsky believes that a truly educated person is curious, open-minded, and willing to explore different perspectives, making them better equipped to navigate a world and contribute meaningfully to the Society.
The Core Principle and requirement of a fulfilled human being is the ability to inquire and create constructively and independantly without external Controls. Futher In the Video he explained that ;
"It is not important what we Cover in the Class but it is important to be seen that what we discover in the Class."
A True education opens a door to human intellectual freedom and creative autonomy. To be truly educated means to be resourceful , to be able to formulate serious questions. It means to Find One's own way through education. I want to end my blog with Putting Some Quotations which is directly connected with what it means to be a truly educated Person.
● " With the help of education People become lifelong learner."
● Through Syllabus, what we discover in the Class - that is very Important."
● " The real understanding begins when we have unanswerable questions."
● " Education is about being life long learner."
□ Here , I end my blog. I hope that it will be helpful to you.
Welcome readers! This blog is written in response to the task given by Megha Ma'am - Department of English, MKBU. This blog is a part of our thinking activity. In this blog, I will discuss some questions related to the Poem "Laxman" written by Toru Dutt. First, Let us discuss about the Poet.
□ Toru Dutt :-
Toru Dutt (In Bengali :- তরু দত্ত; 1856 – 1877) was an Indian Bengali translator and poet from BritishIndia, who wrote in English and French languages. She is among the founding figures of Indo - Anglian literature. She is known for her volumes of poetry in English, Sita, A Sheaf Gleaned in French Fields (1876) and Ancient Ballads and Legends of Hindustan (1882), and for a novel in French, Le Journal de Mademoiselle d'Arvers (1879). Her poems explore themes of loneliness, longing, patriotism and nostalgia.
Toru Dutt was the Youngest of three children, following Sister Aru and brother Abju. She and he siblings spent the majority of their Youth in Calcutta. Toru Dutt was an innate linguist. In her brief life, she learned the languages - Bengali , English , French and Subsequently Sanskrit. She left behind a Substantial body of Poetry and literature. The Only work that was published during Toru’s lifetime was a Sheaf Gleaned in French Fields (1876). This was a Collection of English translations of French poetry that Toru had begun with her elder sister, and was Published by the Saptahik Sambad Press in Calcutta without any preface or introduction. Toru had read Edmund Gosse’s appreciative review of the book in The Examiner of August 1876, but did not live to see the second expanded edition her father Published in 1878 along with a memoir of her, or the illustrious third edition of nearly 200 Poems.
Toru Dutt also left her only English Novel, Bianaca , Or the Young Spanish Maiden, Unfinished. Bianca was later Published Serially in The Bengal Magazine from January to April 1878. Toru Dutt's french novel , Le Journal de Mademoiselle d'Arvers , was Posthumously Published in France in 1879 with an Introduction by Clarisse Bader. Ancient Ballads and Legends of Hindustan , Comprising Toru’s Original Poems , Poetic transcreations and adaptations from Sanskrit literature and Bengali tales was Published Posthumously by Messrs Kegan Paul in London in 1882 with an Introductory memoir by Edmund Gosse on Toru Dutt's life and works.
Toru Dutt died of tuberculosis , at the age of 21 on 30th August , 1877 in Kolkata.
□ Major Works :-
Some of her Major Works include ;
1. " A Sheaf Gleaned in French Fields" (1876)
2. " Ancient Ballads and Legends of Hindustan (1882)
3. " Le Journal de Mademoiselle d'Arvers" (1879)
4. " Our Casuarian Tree "
5. " Lotus "
6. " Lakshman "
7. " My Vocation "
8. " The Broken Bell "
Toru Dutt's writing reflects her multicultural background and her ability to write in multiple languages. Her Works making her a notable Figure in 19th Century Literature.
□ Writing Style :-
As a master of Verse Toru always rises to the Occasion. Besides , her management of the Versification is adorit enough - the 4 - lines ballad Stanza , the 8 - line octosyllabic Stanza, blank verse , Toru is reasonably at home in them all. She has shown the remarkable mastery of the Sonnet Form. There are nearly Forty Sonnets in the Sheaf Gleaned in French Fields and two in Ancient Ballads. Toru Dutt is known for her elegant and lyrical Writing Style.
Her Works often Combine elements of both western and Indian literary traditions, reflecting her multicultural upbringing and influences. She is Particularly Celebrated for her use of Vivid Imagery, metaphors and allusions to Hindu mythology and Culture. Toru Dutt's Poetry Often explores the theme of nature , Love , Spirituality and the Clash of Cultures.
Her Writing is Characterized by its rich language, evocative descriptions and a sense of nostalgia for her native India, even as she was Influenced by European Romanticism and Victorian literature.
□ Laxman Poem :-
The Poem Laxman is from Toru Dutt's 'Ancient Ballads and Legends of Hindustan ' (1882). It tells a story from the Hindu Epic Ramayana in which the hero Rama is told to Procure a golden deer for his Wife Sita. After Rama Leaves Sita with his brother , Laxman for Safekeeping , he finds out that the deer is actually a demon and kills it. However, when the demon dies , it calls out for help using Rama's Own Voice. Though Lakshman knows Rama is invincible and does not Worry , Sita Panics at the sound of the Cry for help and asks Laxman to go and investigate. Laxman draws a line in the ground that Sita is not to cross while he leaves to search for Rama. While he is absent , however Sita crosses the line and is abducted by the demon king Ravena.
The Poem takes this Story from the Ramayana and Opens up the discussion between Sita and Laxman , expanding it beyond what is Present in the epic. Still, much of the Core elements of their dialogue are Preserved from the Epic. The Poem begins with the anxiety of Sita ;
" Hark ! Lakshman Hark, again that Cry !
It is, - It is my husband's Voice !
Oh hasten , to his Succor Fly,
No more hast thou, dear friend a Choice . " (Stanza 1).
This kind of Words from Sita expresses her heightened anxiety as a woman who is scared that her husband is in danger. This Stanza sets the tone of the Poem. The identity of the woman being very frail and Fragile is thus created not only in the mythology but also in this Poem. In Other words Toru Dutt has reconstructed the Same Sita appearing in the mythology and Focused on her Speech.
Future in the Poem , Lakshman logically tries to assure the safety of Ram to Sita by Saying that ;
"Oh Calm thyself , Videhan queen,
No cause is there for any fear ,
Hast thou his Prowess never seen?" (Stanza 4)
And a little later in the Poem , Lakshman gives the examples of Ram's emphatic and Strong presence.
"The lion and the grisly bear
Cower when they see his royal look,
Sun-staring eagles of the air
His glance of anger cannot brook,
Pythons and cobras at his tread
To their most secret coverts glide,
Bowed to the dust each serpent head
Erect before in hooded pride." (Stanza 5).
Through this Stanza we can understand that Laxman's Convincing segment to Sita is full of strong and Ferocious animals like lion, bear, Pythons and Cobras. He does a Comparison which established based on Ram's Potential to fight back. Such images came in our mind like Strength and Fearless attitude of Lord Rama. But all this assurance gets objected with the Sentiments of Wife. When Sita does not get Convinced by Lakshman about the safety of her husband. She fails to send Lakshman out for Rama her anxiety changes to doubt which gets expressed through the allegations on Laxman.
" "He perishes — well, let him die!
His wife henceforth shall be mine own!
Can that thought deep imbedded lie
Within thy heart's most secret zone!
(Stanza 11)
Sita Imagines herself to be an Object which can be Possessed by Lakshman. In Toru Dutt's Poem Lakshman Sita accuses Lakshman for his delay in going out to Save Lord Rama. Sita's mind Changes and She accuses Lakshman by telling that he wanted to marry his brother's wife.
Sita's character in the Poem Lakshman may not be Strictly in keeping with her portrayal in the Ramayana but it is in accordance with human nature , and shows the Working of a Woman's mind. In this Poem she does not appear as an idealized queen , but as a woman who behaves as a woman in her Condition Ought to be. She acts impulsively and easily falls in the trap laid down for her by Ravena , the tricky and mighty king of Lanka. The Charges and allegations Sita levels against Lakshman are humiliating and degrading. Nevertheless, Lakshman stands noble and Sublime. Lakshman's character shines all the more brightly in the face of Sita's accusations against him. Perhaps, this is what has made Toru Dutt to title the Poem " Lakshman" than titling " Sita" though she Plays the role of a Protagonist in the Poem.
Question 1 :- Write a Critical note on Lakshman Poem by Toru Dutt.
Answer :- ' Lakshman' by Toru Dutt is a poem on a Hindu mythological theme. The subject matter of the poem is taken from the ‘Ramayana’, a Sanskrit epic by Valmiki. Lakshman was a younger brother of Sri Ramchandra. Once Ramchandra with his beloved wife, Sita, had to go to exile after his father’s will. With Ram and Sita, Lakshman also went to exile. Sita was chaste, pious and very beautiful. Ravana, the king of Lanka, had heard of Sita’s qualities and hence he desired to carry her off. While Ram, Sita and Lakshman were in exile, Ravana took the avail of it and by his magic power, he created a golden deer. To please Sita, her husband Ram pursued the deer leaving Sita and Lakshman in the bower. Then at distance, Sita heard a voice as same as that of Ram seeking help. Really the voice was not of Ram but of Ravana. Ravana made a plan to drive Lakshman away of the bower so that he can carry Sita off. Sita, hearing the calling of Ravana to be Ram’s, asked Lakshman to go to help Ram. First Lakshman did not want to leave the bower leaving Sita alone. But Sita persistently persuaded Lakshman to leave the bower in order to rescue Ram. The poet Toru Dutt has given a very poetic as well as a dramatic description of Sita’s persuasion to Lakshman. The poem bears the stamp of how much devotion and love Sita had for her husband.
Hearing the voice like that of Ram, Sita says to Lakshman and calls him to go to succour Ram without making any delay. She thinks that perhaps her husband is surrounded by foes, so Lakshman should go there quickly with his sword and bow. But Lakshman seemed not to heed Sita’s order. Then Sita, being angry, wanted to go alone. Seeing Sita’s agitation and anxiety, Lakshman says to Sita that there is no cause to fear because Ram is strong and brave enough to fight an enemy. He then gives a poetic account of Ram’s prowess and says that the lion and bear shrink back in fear when they see his royal look. The anger of Ram none can endure, Even sun-staring eagles drop-down at Ram’s look. Pythons and cobras, at Ram’s tread, glide to their secret holes.
Lakshman anticipated the wailing cry for help is not of Ram but of an enemy uttered to delude them. So Sita should not beseech Lakshman to go out in search of Ram leaving Sita alone. Instead, he made Sita remind her that he had been commanded by Ram to remain with Sita as a guard as there might have some giant foes in the forest to harm her. But Lakshman's persuasion could not calm Sita of her anxiety. Instead, she argued and says that ;
Search well and see! One brother takes
His kingdom— one would take his wife
A fair partitional— but it makes
Me shudder and abhor my life.”
At last , Sita’s allegations towards Lakshman he tracing a magic circle in front of the door, and Ordering her not to cross the Circle, goes to help Lord Rama. After Lakshman 's departure Ravena came to the bower and Carried off Sita to Lanka.
The poem shows Sita’s devotion and love to her husband; but Sita herself is responsible for being carried away by Ravana, the king of Lanka. Besides this Lakshman's wisdom is also presented in the the Poem and We can also see that how Sita Puts blame and allegations towards Lakshman but still he stands as Nobel and Loyal. He knows that he has a mission in life - that of serving his brother.
● Conclusion :- To Conclude , Toru Dutt's Poem Lakshman tells the tragic tale of Lakshman , Lord Rama's loyal brother. Through Vivid Imagery and emotional depth , Dutt explores themes of duty, sacrifice and Complexities of familial love. This Poem is a long narrative one, Consisting total twenty - two Stanzas.